Mane Choice vs Shea Moisture

By | May 11, 2021

Our hair is an important part that affects the whole confidence and bad hair day will ruin your mood as well. Especially for people with thick and curly hair, it is difficult to maintain the shape and look which is why a proper hair care such as those from Mane Choice Vs Shea Moisture will be very helpful. These brands have a dedicated line for curly hair and if you wonder which looks more promising, do give our short comparison below a read.

In this comparison, we are going to talk about:

  • How to Care for Curly Hair
  • What are Mane Choice and Shea Moisture
  • How are the Shampoo of Mane Choice and Shea Moisture
  • What are the Ingredients of Mane Choice and Shea Moisture
  • What are the Benefits of Mane Choice and Shea Moisture
  • How are the Results of Mane Choice and Shea Moisture
  • Mane Choice Vs Shea Moisture

Curly Hair Care

Caring for hair can be as easy as it sounds or stressful for some of us, especially those who suffer from hair problems or have tricky hair types such as curly hair. Whether you have 3C or 4C type, we have to put more thorough care to prevent various typical issues such as dry, brittle, frizz or just an undefined look. All of us want beautiful and shiny hair but sadly it often does not come naturally and we have to put an effort into achieving it.

The first common mistake we often have done to the hair is over cleansing or washing the hair too frequently. Shampooing is completely depending on the hair type and individual need such as how active they are or the weather where they live. Those busy or active people may sweat more and need to wash more often but over cleansing will cause dryness which triggers the scalp to produce even more sebum. And, since natural curl needs the oil to moisturize hair, keeping the wash one to twice a week is recommended.

The second common mistake is skipping conditioner and we understand that not all people like to do this additional step but, the goal of conditioning hair is to prevent dry, dull, and frizzy hair which is what we are trying to do here. Try finding a hydrating conditioner or formulation made for curly hair so we can get the optimum benefit that can’t be achieved by the shampoo alone. For a tip, if your curls are flat on top, try rinsing the hair upside down instead of with your head back.

The third mistake is waiting too long before applying styling products. For some people such as with straight or wavy hair, air drying naturally is great to prevent hair damage but for curly hairs, we can set the shape better when they are still damped and waiting too long can cause the frizz to settle before we can shape the curl. Do put the products when the hair damp and work the hands through the hair without too much raking motion to prevent frizz.

Drying the hair properly is also crucial in defining the curls that last long but, unlike with most people, we have to use the diffuser on the dryer to work better. This is meant to limit the heat transferred to the hair to prevent drying them and since the air will be even more distributed, it prevents the hair from being tossed away roughly thus, creating less friction and frizz once dried.

 Mane Choice Shea Moisture
Product Dimensions1.9 x 1.9 x 7.3 inches3 x 3 x 5.5 inches
Shipping Weight6.4 Ounces
14.4 Ounces
Best offerCheck priceCheck price

About Mane Choice and Shea Moisture

It sounds too much but will be worth it once we are used to the proper care, moreover if you have experienced extreme dryness. Additionally, choosing the suitable products tailored for curly hair or combining topical and hair vitamins such as Hairfinity Vs Nature’s Bounty will be very helpful to care for the hair from the outside and inside. Hair care solutions made for curly hairs are usually more nourishing and helpful to address the common hair issues, mostly about dryness and maintaining the shape.

Since curly hair is a very common type, chances are you will find a proper line from many hair care brands out there such as Mane Choice and Shea Moisture. In comparison, you may be more familiar to Mane Choice as a brand of hair supplement and this is because they are quite popular as well for the vitamins that can help people to grow hair faster. Shea Moisture on the other hand is more well-known for their curly hair specialized products.

Both brands carry a wide range of hair care systems but Shea Moisture is focusing on the topical solutions while Mane Choice also has the supplementation. In comparison the two will be a great choice for those who are looking to buy or renew their hair care system but today we are going to focus on the basic care which is the shampoo from both lines. These shampoos are Easy on Curl and Curl & Shine from the respective brands.

Shampoo is the basic hair care that all of us have to use routinely depending on the hair’s need. They are also playing a huge role in both cleansing and caring for the hair because for curly hair we also want the shampoo to not be as drying. These shampoos from Mane Choice and Shea Moisture are tailored to maintain the moisture while cleansing and removing buildup from the scalp and hair. However, both do have different formulations and not all of us will experience the same benefits.

Mane Choice and Shea Moisture Shampoos

When getting a new product whether it is hair or body care, we often smell them first to decide whether they will feel good to apply or not. While it may not affect the benefits, it is a huge plus to have good scented products and we do love how Mane Choice and Shea Moisture are created. For Mane Choice the smell of this shampoo is fresh or rather fruity if we may say, some people say it smells like grapes or mixed berries, it is a comforting scent in our opinion.

On the other hand Shea Moisture is a bit milky probably because it uses coconut and if you have coconut based products they probably smell similar, still easy on the nose and pleasant to apply. The shampoo itself is almost similar in consistency, they are neither creamy nor thick but more of a combination between cream and gel. They create plenty of foam which is surprising since both are sulfate-free.

Mane Choice and Shea Moisture Ingredients

Just like with any product, we have to check their ingredients first before deciding the choice because you may have to avoid some of them. Starting with Mane Choice, this shampoo is using olefin sulfonate as the surfactant or foaming agent and is added with plenty of beneficial ingredients. Some of them are biotin, nettle extract, clary extract, chamomile extract, and silk amino acids. On the other hand Shea Moisture is using decyl glucoside as a mild surfactant to clean the hair along with sodium lauroyl lactylate.

This shampoo is also added with moisturizing agents such as hydrolyzed silk, coconut fruit juice, shea butter, coconut oil, aloe vera leaf juice, and hibiscus flower extract. Both shampoos are added with fragrance but the Shea Moisture is using a blend of essential oil to create the more natural smells which is also certified organics.

Mane Choice and Shea Moisture Benefits

Moving further, let’s see what Mane Choice and Shea Moisture may offer to you. What piques our interest is biotin in Mane Choice since this B vitamin is usually taken as supplement. But, it seems the benefit of the vitamin is also visible from topical application by strengthening existing strands and reduces splits or breakage which is prominent in curly hair while nourishing the scalp. Both shampoos also include silk in their ingredients and this is great to reinforce the hair as silk itself is known to be the strongest natural fiber.

Another good ingredient is clary extract or sage extract which is useful to help cleansing oil on the hair and maintaining oil production so besides cleanliness, we get the balance of our scalp back. Since Shea Moisture is using coconut, we can hope to see a stronger hair since the ingredient is working like silk protein by nourishing and strengthening the hair, reducing brittle and improving a healthier look.

Mane Choice and Shea Moisture Results

The results of Mane Choice and Shea Moisture shampoos are satisfying and our favorite is they don’t dry the hair as much as typical shampoos but they are not as moisturizing as well if you won’t add any conditioner after. We highly recommend using the conditioner from these lines as well for optimum moisture but when it comes to detangling effects, Shea Moisture is working better. As for the feeling, besides clean, we also find the hair is smoother when it dries after using these shampoos.

Mane Choice vs Shea Moisture

Both Mane Choice and Shea Moisture curly hair line products are great alternatives if your hair is drying using the previous shampoos. They have a complete solution for daily hair care and with plenty of useful ingredients, the two are delivering great benefit as well. We do think Mane Choice has a better scent since we personally like fresh fragrances but on the moisturizing and detangling effects, it seems Shea Moisture is working better here by leaving the hair easy to style and smoother when dried.

- SUPPORT NATURAL HAIR GROWTH AND RETENTION: Easy On The Curls Detangling Hydration Shampoo supports the natural hair growth and retention. Its formula is enriched with Biotin and Vitamin E to promote healthier, longer, and thicker hair.
- NO MORE DRY AND STRIPPED FEELING: This shampoo formula is enriched with Vitamin E to nourish, grow and hydrate your hair. You can finally look forward to washing build-up and impurities out of your hair without those annoying knots and tangles.
- WASH BUILD-UP & IMPURITIES AWAY: This shampoo gently yet effectively cleanses and removes build-up without stripping the hair, leaving it feeling soft and shiny. A clean hair and scalp are essential for a perfectly healthy hair growth regime.
- SULFATE-FREE & PARABEN-FREE: Easy On The Curls Detangling Hydration Shampoo contains no Mineral Oil, Petrolatum, Parabens or Sulfates to ensure the best care for you and your hair.
- SheaMoisture Curl and Shine Shampoo is a phthalate free shampoo, paraben free shampoo and cruelty-free, that hair gently cleanses natural hair and improves hair's health and restores shine.
- This curl enhancing shampoo is a natural hair shampoo that contains coconut oil to moisturize and protect hair while replenishing lost oil.
- SheaMoisture delivers this silicone free shampoo that is a curl care shampoo and also contains hibiscus flower extracts to improve hair elasticity while reducing the occurrence of breakage.
- The rich, creamy lather of SheaMoisture’s coconut and hibiscus women's shampoo and daily shampoo gently washes away impurities, leaving you with frizz free waves and curls


You can opt for any of these shampoos since your hair may have different conditions but we do recommend trying Shea Moisture first because most people seem to find this shampoo more effective in moisturizing their hair.