Neutrogena T Gel vs Head and Shoulders

By | July 5, 2021

Anti-dandruff shampoos are very common and all have the same claims to remove dandruff as well as improving your hair and scalp health. Neutrogena T Gel Vs Head and Shoulders are among the most popular anti-dandruff shampoos in the market but they are using different active ingredients to make the solution work. Depending on the cause of your hair issue, our choice can be different and before deciding to choose one, let’s see what they can offer below.

In this comparison, we are going to talk about:

  • Are You Currently Looking for an Anti-Dandruff Solution
  • What are Neutrogena T Gel and Head and Shoulders
  • How are the Solution of Neutrogena T Gel and Head and Shoulders
  • What are the Ingredients of Neutrogena T Gel and Head and Shoulders
  • What are the Benefits of Neutrogena T Gel and Head and Shoulders
  • How are the Result with Neutrogena T Gel and Head and Shoulders
  • Neutrogena T Gel Vs Head and Shoulders

Anti-Dandruff Solution

Hair is like the natural protective part of our body to cover the scalp and also as an accessory that improves your appearance. Hairstyle is often related to the person’s head shape and face to match the appearance they want to have and yes, this includes those who prefer to shave their head clean. Just like with our other body parts, hair and scalp can often experience some problems in which one of the most common is dandruff. It is not dangerous for our overall well being but can be very annoying.

Dandruff itself is rooting from the scalp condition that causes the skin to be itchy and followed by flakes of dead skin. People usually experience it around puberty and start to subside as they reach older ages and nearing 50 years. They can be a light issue or can be more severe because they are varying from case to case so what we have felt may not be the same to other people despite both of us having similar hair issues. In some cases, the severe condition will require professional help through medication.

For those who wonder what causes dermatitis, the most common trigger is seborrheic dermatitis or seborrhea. People with dry skin, or sensitive against certain hair products and other skin conditions like eczema or psoriasis will be most likely to have dandruff. Another cause of seborrhea besides stress and genes is also yeast or also called fungus that live in our skin called malassezia. This fungus is increasing skin cell growth and the extra skin cells will die off then producing those flakes we always hate.

If you are not sure whether you have dandruff or not, the initial symptoms will be itchy scalp and then the flakes will show shortly. It can be seen from the scalp that has redness and greasy patches as well which sometimes can give you a tingly feeling. Some other symptoms may cause dryness, tightness, or irritation of the scalps. In general dandruff usually gets better during warmer weather but it doesn’t mean people living in warmer climates don’t experience dandruff. 

Dandruff usually only requires topical solution and the shampoo is often enough to cure the condition. Usually doctors will recommend or prescribe shampoo with pyrithione zinc which is known for its antibacterial and antifungal effects. You can also try coal based shampoos in order to keep the fungal growth suppressed. It is probably best to use more than one shampoo with these active ingredients and rotate them to prevent the tolerance against the same product.

 Neutrogena T Gel Head and Shoulders

Product Dimensions1.97 x 1.97 x 5.91 inches1.76 x 3.03 x 8.31 inches
Shipping Weight8.82 Ounces1.07 Pounds
Best offerCheck priceCheck price

About Neutrogena T Gel and Head and Shoulders

Now when you already have an idea about why dandruff exists and how to deal with the issue, it is time to see what the solutions are. Unlike hair loss that is often treated from the inside such as using supplements like Hairfinity Vs Viviscal, dandruff can be kept at bay with the right shampoo. These shampoos are formulated with not only cleansing agents and moisturizers but also active ingredients to cure or at least suppress the trigger of dandruff which is seborrhea. 

But, because they are very common the options are also abundantly available out there and this can be confusing as well. If you don’t have much time or patience to browse around these options, we can see what other people are choosing since they have a higher chance to also fit your condition. Among those, Neutrogena and Head and Shoulders are two promising options to consider. These famous shampoos are easy to find so we are sure everyone can grab one and try them at home.

In comparison, Neutrogena is more expensive than the typical H&S shampoos but they are also effective. The Neutrogena T Gel and Head and Shoulders are promising solutions for your dandruff and as it has been mentioned above, it is better to alternate the products to prevent building up tolerance against the same shampoo or active ingredients. In comparison, the two are using different main agents to cure or at least keep the issue at bay.

Neutrogena T Gel is relying on the coal tar as its active ingredients while the Head and Shoulders is using Pyrithione Zinc which is why they are both effective for dandruff. Most people find these shampoos to be very cleansing so if you have itchy scalp because of the flakes, they will be able to improve the comfort as well. In comparison, this is what sets them apart the most but the result for everyone can vary as well. In addition, the H&S shampoo we choose today is their classic clean as you can find plenty of variants in the collection.

Neutrogena T Gel and Head and Shoulders Solution

These shampoos are very similar to those we have used in the past in terms of scent but in comparison the Neutrogena is not as friendly for everyone just in case you have a sensitive nose because it can be too strong for some people. It is fragrance based, not herbs like so it may need some time to get used to them. For H&S, this has a fresh and rather flowery scent with sweet notes to it and if it is not to your liking, this brand carries a huge range of anti-dandruff shampoos.

The Neutrogena T Gel has this golden/amber color that is not creamy at all. It is like gel with transparent consistency but can be easily blended with water and applied to hair or scalp directly. H&S shampoos are creamy and light in comparison but due to this sometimes when the shampoo is almost finished and we flip the bottle to easily dispense its solution, they will leak around the opening and out of the cap as well. 

Neutrogena T Gel and Head and Shoulders Ingredients

Now for the most important part, let’s see the active ingredients of Neutrogena T Gel and Head and Shoulders. The T Gel is based on coal tar or the Neutar Solubilized which is owned by Neutrogena and is functioning the same with other anti-dandruff shampoos active ingredients. On the other hand, the H&S shampoo is based on Pyrithione Zinc but the amount of these ingredients are different because with coal tar the efficacy only needs to be at 0.5% while Zinc needs to be 1% to deliver the benefit.

Neutrogena T Gel and Head and Shoulders Benefits

Coal tar is safe to use and is regulated by the FDA to treat psoriasis. It is working by slowing down the rapid growth of skin cells since it can also suppress the growth of the fungus that causes these effects. In general it will also reduce the flakes and irritation related to the issue including the itchy feeling. Since it is keratolytic, its other advantage is to soften and loosen the scales or crust. They need to be 0.5% to work but the higher the concentration, the more effective it is against fungus. 

Moving to the pyrithione zinc, this active ingredient is very common being used in anti-dandruff shampoos as it is very effective. It can heal the scalp by normalizing the epithelial keratinization or sebum production. The significant benefits, it has antibacterial, antimicrobial, and antifungal properties that can help treat seborrheic dermatitis or called as dandruff and psoriasis. This is because it can inhibit the growth of yeast. The pyrithione zinc is derived from the chemical element zinc, and can be used directly to skin.

Neutrogena T Gel and Head and Shoulders Result

Now for the result, it may vary whether you choose to use which shampoos since our skin can react differently as well. The problem with coal tar shampoo usually is the smell since they have this strange scent and for many, can be unpleasant too. The shampoo is actually very effective if you can bear with the scent and we also recommend using conditioner only on the hair strands or from the middle of your hair length to reduce the unpleasant smell.

H&S on the other hand is almost like any other shampoos out there and doesn’t have any weird scent. It lather well and leave your hair and scalp clean but not as drying as the coal tar based shampoos. If your hair tends to get very dry when using anti-dandruff shampoos, we recommend trying the 2in1 variant as it is more moisturizing.

Neutrogena T Gel vs Head and Shoulders

Both of them are very promising solutions for those who have experienced dandruff and are currently looking for an effective shampoo. The coal tar is known to slow the growth of the fungus that causes skin cells production which results in flakes and inflammation while pyrithione zinc is killing the fungus so both will be very effective against the issue. But, the scent is better with H&S as it is similar to most regular shampoos.

- 16-fluid ounce bottle of Neutrogena T/gel therapeutic and anti-dandruff shampoo to get long lasting relief from itching and flaking
- Original therapeutic formula helps control scalp itching and flaking caused by chronic scalp psoriasis, seborrheic dermatitis and even common dandruff
- Contains coal tar extract, which scientific tests have proved continues to work for hours after the shampoo is rinsed off
- This dandruff treatment shampoo helps maintain a healthy scalp and leaves hair clean and manageable.
- Head & Shoulders Classic Clean Anti-Dandruff shampoo fights flakes and leaves your scalp clean
- From the scalp care experts; the makers of America's #1 dandruff shampoo* (*based on volume sales)
- Multi-symptom relief offers proven protection from flakes, itch* and dryness (*flakes and itch associated with dandruff)
- Nourishes to relieve dandruff symptoms while cleansing hair and scalp* (*with regular use)


You can try any of the two but H&S is more affordable in comparison and you can opt for this shampoo first but, we also recommend trying the similar choice like Neutrogena to make sure we can get the best result from both.